Back to Posts
Mar 11, 2019

Why the Discipleship Method Is Not Enough

Dan DeMatte

In recent years, there has been a major shift in Catholic ministry culture promoting and implementing what has popularly been called the “discipleship method.” I want to start by suggesting that I love the modern push to re-emphasize discipleship. There is an urgent need for effective small group ministry and intentional one-on-one discipling of Christians. Small group ministry consistently bears abundant fruit in communities that have well-formed leaders who know how to form—what Sherry Weddell and now many others call—intentional disciples. This move toward intentional discipleship through small group ministry and discipleship-based relationships is absolutely critical and extremely effective.

While I would never suggest this movement should stop, I want to strongly emphasize that the discipleship method, by itself, is not enough.

In an effort to promote small group ministry and one-on-one discipleship relationships, many people have come out as critics to “large group style ministry.” In an effort to encourage the one, they have overly critiqued, and in many cases, altogether done away with the other. This is an incredibly huge mistake. Without large-group ministry, the discipleship method will never bear the long-term fruit it promises.

Effectively Forming Apostles

I’ve been in ministry for fifteen years, implementing a large group style ministry program with very intentional small group and one-on-one discipleship efforts integrated into the model. In fifteen years, I have seen incredible fruit, absolutely incredible fruit. Hundreds and hundreds of youth who have been impacted by my ministry have entered into adulthood and are living as active and conscious believers. They have been married in the Church, and they are living according to God’s vision for the laity.

But even more, hundreds of those who have been impacted by my ministry are living lives of active ministry, either through the priesthood, religious life, or lay ministry. Sixty-five percent of the seminarians in our diocese have come out of my parish or lay apostolate ministry efforts. These missionary disciples are engaged in every strata of ministry service, including the work of evangelization, Catholic education, social care for the poor, healing ministry, pro-life work. You name it, we have alumni engaged in it in some way, shape, or form. They are orthodox, well-formed, and have a missionary spirit.

Large-group ministry is necessary. Without large-group ministry, not only are we not living the gospel, but we will often fail to form missionary disciples. Sure, you may form disciples, but are we effectively forming apostles?

Large Group Ministry

The discipleship method is often referred to as “Jesus’ style of ministry” because Jesus chose twelve followers and invested deeply in them, shared life with them, and then, sent them on mission to transform the world. According to the discipleship method, we should imitate Jesus in finding small groups of people, investing deeply in them, teaching them how to live like Jesus lived, and then, send them off as disciple-making disciples.

The idea is simple: If I form three disciple-making disciples, and each of those three form three disciple-making disciples, the number just keeps getting larger and larger over time—like compound interest. It’s a beautiful concept and should continue being taught and promoted.  

Yes, this was Jesus’ style of ministry, BUT this wasn’t all that Jesus did. In fact, how did Jesus form his twelve disciples into apostles? Jesus didn’t host weekly small group gatherings at Peter’s mom’s house! No, Jesus formed missionary disciples through having them step into leadership roles in his large group ministry!

Christ Formed Evangelists

The Gospels are very clear. Jesus did not just spend his three years in public ministry only ministering to twelve people. Jesus was, in fact, an itinerate preacher, traveling from city to city ministering to “the multitude.” The multitude! Over and over and over again, the Gospels reference this multitude in different cities. Far more than just twelve men followed him from city to city, and far more gathered around him as he preached and healed.

There are clear references to the five thousand men (not counting the women and children) gathered with him. The Gospels also mention the three thousand gathered around him. There are references to the five hundred gathered around him. The Sermon on the Mount was a ministry event that gathered thousands. Very clearly, Jesus constantly—no matter where he was and what he was doing—had a multitude with him.

It is also very clear that he was forming missionary disciples out of this multitude. He doesn’t just commission the twelve, but in Luke 10, Jesus commissions the seventy-two! There are seventy-two very close disciples that Jesus was willing to send out to “Heal the sick ,”who are there and tell them, ‘The kingdom of God is at hand.’” Jesus didn’t spend his ministry career just forming twelve missionary disciples! Jesus formed healers and preachers, and he sends them forth. He formed evangelists!

He Formed Intentional Leaders

For Jesus, there’s the five thousand, the three thousand, the five hundred, the seventy-two, the twelve, and the three. There’s small group ministry and one-on-one formation, but there is also clearly large group ministry. And this is PRECISELY why the twelve (and the seventy-two) became world-changing apostles who were missionary disciples.

Without the multitude, you cannot effectively disciple. Jesus’ style of ministry is both large group ministry and small group ministry. In fact, it’s within the large group ministry that Jesus raises up his apostles, those in his small group.

In the three years Jesus had with these twelve men, I believe he was placing them in critical positions of leadership while he was ministering to the multitude! After all, they were his closest friends. Clearly, he was teaching them healing and deliverance ministry or else he wouldn’t commission them to go and heal the sick and cast out demons. Jesus formed intentional apostles! He formed intentional leaders!

Supernatural Gifting

While Jesus was ministering to the multitude, “They ran throughout that whole region and carried the sick on mats to wherever they heard he was. 

And wherever he went—into villages, towns or countryside—they placed the sick in the marketplaces. They begged him to let them touch even the edge of his cloak, and all who touched it were healed.” (Mark 6:55-56)

And because of this, when Jesus commissions the disciples:

“They went out and preached that people should repent. They drove out many demons and anointed many sick people with oil and healed them” (Mark 6:12-13).

Sure, we could argue that the Holy Spirit transformed the apostles and made them incredible missionaries that transformed the world, but we all know that grace builds on nature. I’ve been baptized with fire over and over again in my life, drinking deeply of the living waters of the Holy Spirit, but the Holy Spirit, more often than not, propels my natural talent into supernatural talent, my natural gifting into supernatural gifting.

Why Limit Ourselves to Coffee Shops?

What if Jesus didn’t have twelve uneducated and under-qualified apostles following him stupidly for three years, like we often suggest? We often suggest these men were unfaithful fools until the Holy Spirit came upon them at Pentecost. But in Jesus’ three years of public ministry, it seems to me that Jesus used large group ministry to the multitude in order to teach the apostles how to draw from and minister to the multitude! What if Jesus taught them how to preach and teach to the masses? What if Jesus taught them the leadership and communication skills necessary to form the Church and transform peoples’ lives, and then, when the Holy Spirit came upon them, they were emboldened to do in the supernatural what they were already trained to do in the natural?

Jesus formed leaders, not just followers

And he intentionally formed these aforementioned apostles to be leaders! It even appears that the way in which he does this is through inviting them into his ministry to the multitude. Immediately after Pentecost, the apostles draw a multitude! After Pentecost, the apostles don’t wander off and each find three people to have one-on-ones with at the local Starbucks. No!

Transforming the Culture

Instead, three thousand people gather, and Peter preaches the gospel to them and they are cut to the heart and ask what they must do. Peter tells them to “repent and be baptized,” and what do you think follows that? I bet all the apostles who had just received the outpouring of the Holy Spirit prayed over those present for a release of the Holy Spirit that they too might be baptized in the Holy Spirit. Large group ministry. The multitude.

St. Paul clearly takes men like Timothy and Titus under his wing and disciples them, but he doesn’t hang out in Chipotle with them reading through the Psalms. Instead, he brings them with him while he ministers to entire nations and through this, they are formed into missionary disciples —apostles who are capable of leading a movement and transforming cities!

What’s the Solution?

I propose a new term, and perhaps, a new way of doing ministry, I call it the Apostleship Method. I believe that we need to not only form intentional disciples, but we need to form intentional apostles. We need to be forming missionary disciples who are empowered and equipped to minister to others, and I believe the simplest way we accomplish this is by forming leadership teams within a discipleship context that help execute the large group ministry.

If you want to draw one hundred people to an event, form a leadership team of ten people, each commissioned to bring ten people to the event. Then, while ministering to the multitude, teach those ten how to create an environment of encounter with Jesus. Teach them how to engage with others and how to pray with others and how to disciple others. Pass your gifts onto them. Make them leaders, not followers.  

My biggest concern with the discipleship method is that it is aimed at finding followers and not forming leaders. We need a new method of ministry that orients us toward leadership development to reach the masses. An apostle is one whom God sends. He or she has the ability to raise up preachers and teachers, evangelists and pastors. An apostle forms other apostles into leaders, and then, in turn, knows how to form leaders.

Leadership. This is what the Church is craving right now. We need leaders.


Photo by Quintin Gellar from Pexels


You May Also Like:

Small Groups: An Ancient Idea for a Digital Age

From Desert to Parish: The Challenge of Making Disciples

Comfortably Uncomfortable: The Challenge of Evangelization


Get your favorite Ascension content sent right to your email!

  • >