Back to Posts
Apr 15, 2019

Easter or Christmas? Which Is More Important?

Nicholas LaBanca

It’s that time of year again. People are getting into the Easter spirit by singing their favorite Easter-themed songs, picking out their ugly Easter egg sweaters, and trying to figure out who they will be getting assigned to for the annual “secret Easter egg basket” at work.

Does this sound familiar to you? I’m guessing probably not, as this most likely sounds a little bit more like the busy preparation for Christmas Day. In truth, many people in our Western culture overlook Easter as just another day. They see it as a kind of preparation or welcoming of springtime. In one way, we should be happy about this, as the religious connotation to Easter has not been totally removed.

While many people in secular society celebrate Christmas with a big dinner and party, it is mainly Christians that celebrate the day of our Lord Jesus’ Resurrection each year. But since we live in the world, a corresponding commercialization of Easter has led many Christians, including Catholics, to see Easter as somewhat as a “lesser” holiday. It’s already on a weekend, it’s not a national holiday, and no one is singing Easter carols! So this begs the question: is Easter actually more important than Christmas?

Conquering Death’s Sting

While both Easter and Christmas Day are solemnities, the highest rank of a feast on the Church’s calendar, the short answer is that Easter is indeed the most important day of the entire liturgical year. Our first indication of this comes from our weekly worship each Sunday. It would be entirely proper to say that each and every Sunday of the entire year is a “little Easter”. Whether or not that Sunday falls in Advent, Ordinary Time, or Lent, each Sunday celebrates the Resurrection, the day of new creation.

This is why it is acceptable for us to relax our penances on Sundays during Lent. That’s also why we typically do not observe penitential practices on other Sundays throughout the year. This is because we rejoice on each Sunday. If each Sunday give us a little taste of the great feast of Easter, then it’s no wonder that we are able to … well, feast! This is particularly apparent in the Eastern Catholic Churches. There, the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass (or Divine Liturgy) is not celebrated on any other day of Lent except Sundays and major feasts like the Annunciation. Sunday is a day set apart specifically because it was the day that our Lord Jesus rose from the dead, conquering death’s sting once and for all (see 1 Corinthians 15:55-57).

Birth and Rebirth

Next, we must also consider that Christians started celebrating Easter well before they started celebrating Christmas Day. The early Christians were well aware that the day of the Lord’s Resurrection, Sunday, was now a special day. The Sabbath was no longer observed on Saturdays, but on Sundays in remembrance of the Resurrection. But the commemoration of the Lord’s birth was something that came relatively late. In fact, many local Churches celebrated the Epiphany of the Lord before the date for Christmas had become solidified on the calendar around the third century. But why the reason for not giving Christ’s birth precedence over other feasts? One of the Church Fathers, Origen, explains why:

“Not one from all the saints is found to have celebrated a festive day or a great feast on the day of his birth. No one is found to have had joy on the day of the birth of his son or daughter. Only sinners rejoice over this kind of birthday. For indeed we find in the Old Testament Pharaoh, king of Egypt, celebrating the day of his birth with a festival, and in the New Testament, Herod… But the saints not only do not celebrate a festival on their birth days, but, filled with the Holy Spirit, they curse that day.”

(Homilies on Leviticus 8:2)

These are pretty severe words for Westerners today who sometimes like to celebrate “birthday weeks” or even “birthday months”. Again, our culture today puts a lot of emphasis on birthdays into the natural world, but not so much on truly important days, such as the date of one’s baptism. The early Christians were very much aware of the fact that the world was the domain of the prince of darkness. As the Catechism of the Catholic Church puts it:

“After that first sin, the world is virtually inundated by sin.”

(CCC 401)

New Life

Naturally, many of the first Christians would rather focus on their rebirth in Christ instead of their birth into the natural world. Since baptism allows us to take part in the death and resurrection of Jesus, we too die to our old selves and are reborn as a new creation. This is why Origen speaks so harshly about the commemoration of birthdays. It is much more fitting to focus on one’s new life instead of their old.

However, Jesus being sinless, his birth is somewhat different on this account from our own. This is why we eventually see Christians celebrating Christmas, and why we should celebrate this feast of his birth. But as Origen shows us, commemorating the birth of our Lord was far from their minds.

Much closer to the minds of the early Christians was the Incarnation itself. As the Ukrainian Catholic catechism, Christ Our Pascha recounts:

“The Incarnation of the Son of God reveals the purpose of the created world.”

(Christ Our Pascha, 102)

The Mystery of the Resurrection

We celebrate the Incarnation on the same day as the Annunciation. As Mary made her “Yes” to God’s will, she became pregnant with her very creator. Truly, at that moment, the Word had become flesh. A few months later. St. John the Baptist leapt in his own mother’s womb as he found himself in close proximity with the unborn Jesus. So as we can see, Jesus’ presence in the world was felt long before his actual birth into the world.

Now keep in mind that all of this is not to put Christmas down. It certainly is a most important feast, and actually ranks second in degree of solemnity throughout the Church, but we must be aware that other feasts like the Annunciation and the Epiphany are very important moments in the life of Christ as well. But the way that the Church talks about Easter just puts this solemnity on a completely other level. Consider what the Catechism has to say regarding the importance of this feast:

“Therefore Easter is not simply one feast among others, but the ‘Feast of feasts,’ the ‘Solemnity of solemnities,’ just as the Eucharist is the ‘Sacrament of sacraments’ (the Great Sacrament). St. Athanasius calls Easter ‘the Great Sunday’ and the Eastern Churches call Holy Week ‘the Great Week.’ The mystery of the Resurrection, in which Christ crushed death, permeates with its powerful energy our old time, until all is subjected to him.”

(CCC 1169)

United with Christ

“Feast of feasts” is certainly a very accurate way of describing Easter. Just look at the Easter Vigil, for example, with its copious amount of readings, as well as the welcoming of catechumens and other candidates into the Church. Everything in the Church’s calendar works toward the primacy of Easter. This is especially apparent following Easter Sunday. While we celebrate Twelve Days of Christmas every winter, the Easter Season gets a full forty days, not to mention the entire week after Easter Sunday is a proper solemnity in itself. Realistically, given the perennial importance of this feast, the Easter Season could really last even longer, and it does, in a way, with every Sunday recalling the Resurrection. And all this is because of the great chance that our Lord Jesus has given us; that we may become like him.

With death now completely trampled and conquered, Jesus gives us a glimpse into how our own lives will be one day, so long as we love him by keeping his commandments. We have hope in Jesus through his resurrection, and it is something we can relate to on a deeper level than his birth into the world. Yes, we were all born to human mothers just like Jesus was, but it was Jesus’ life as a whole that we truly have solidarity with. St. Paul reminds us:

We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, so that as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life. For if we have been united with him in a death like his, we shall certainly be united with him in a resurrection like his.

(Romans 6:4-5)

Set Free from Sin

Jesus suffered immensely during his passion and crucifixion. But because he underwent this freely, he knows exactly how we as humans suffer. Alternatively, since we have found ourselves baptized into new life, we now have a taste of that resurrection that Christ underwent, looking forward to the happy day when we share in this reality in its entirety upon our entry into heaven. Jesus has prepared the way for us, and it only makes sense that we recognize Easter Day as the greatest of all feasts.

While you might be hard pressed to find people gathering around a table singing Easter hymns outside of Church, it’s clear that Easter is the largest festival that we as Christians celebrate. But we must never overlook the fact that we have that “little Easter” to celebrate each weekend.

How do we bring the Easter message to others each week? Do we represent to others the hope that comes from knowing we will have a glorified body one day, just like our Lord’s? Do we have the hopeful expectation that we will reign by our Lord’s side in heaven? Jesus rose again so that we might become like him. As sons and daughters of God, we share in his likeness, and that even includes the way that he appeared following the Resurrection.

This season, let’s be more aware of the great significance of Easter Sunday, and really, for the entire forty days of Easter. One day, God-willing, we will become like Christ, and this is only a possibility because of the triumphant Resurrection. By that same Resurrection, Christ set us free from sin, and this notion is something that we must keep at the forefront of our minds every day.


You May Also Like:

Christmas, Easter, and Pentecost are Equal in Importance

The Story of Easter Calls Us to Evangelize

Easter Sunday: How Jesus’ Resurrection Changed the Church (video)


About Nicholas LaBanca

Nicholas is a cradle Catholic and hopes to give a unique perspective on life in the Church as a millennial. His favorite saints include his patron St. Nicholas, St. Ignatius of Loyola, St. Thomas Aquinas, St. John Mary Vianney, and St. Athanasius of Alexandria.


Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay

Get your favorite Ascension content sent right to your email!

>

FREE Catholic Bible Reading Plan

This guide lists Scripture in an order that is easy to understand. Sign up for our email list to get it FREE.

FREE Guide to Living Out the Easter Message

Learn what the women on the way to Christ's tomb signify, how Emmaus prefigures the Mass, and how to best accept the risen Christ. Sign up for our email list to get it FREE.