What Makes a Great Catechist (or a Terrible One)

CALLING ALL DIRECTORS OF RELIGIOUS EDUCATION AND CATECHISTS! This one’s for you. Dave “Cucumber Melon” VanVickle and I talk about the qualities that make for bad catechists vs. great catechists and how to find the right people for your program. This is a huge issue for religious education that is so important because the immortal souls of kids depends on it.

We also have storytime with Dave on why Kenny Baldwin is A MONSTER (just kidding) and extend an extra-special welcome to long-time listener Ralph “The Party” VanVickle!

We want to hear from you! Email us at eksb@ascensionpress.com with your story, question, or comment—or if you’ve got a new nickname for Dave.


 What makes a good catechist? 

  • You have a mature spiritual life with daily prayer and a mentality of fides quaerens intellectum or “faith seeking understanding”.
  • You have an answer to this question: “Can you tell me about your daily lived relationship with the Lord?” 
  • You prioritize the truths of the Faith and always tie them to the Person of Christ. 
  • In the classroom, you make sure any craft or art project is truly effective and relevant to the lesson. 
  • You understand that you are making a difference to the immortal souls of your students.
  • You have a DRE who is responsible for ongoing formation of catechists.

What makes a bad catechist? 

  • Unprepared, you haven’t read it or prayed about it.
  • You don’t know your kids’ names.
  • You never pray for them.
  • You don’t quote the Bible.
  • You never share your story of God’s movement in your life.
  • You don’t think about conversion, only communicating the doctrine.
  • You don’t see the whole and how it is all interrelated to Christ and the Trinity.
  • Prayer is nothing but a bookend to your class.

How to find good catechists

  • Start a Bible study or adult faith formation event (or go to one that already exists) and see who shows up consistently and is serious about growing in their faith.
  • Invite specific people to be catechists. Don’t advertise to the whole church. You’re looking for people who are called, not guilted into it.
  • Do a ministry fair where people can come and see what ministries your parish has. 
  • Pray and ask God for good catechists.
  • Be comfortable letting people go.


  1. Personal Prayer Time: Ephesians 4:1-16 
  2. Memorize Catechesi Tradendae center of paragraph five.
  3. Handwrite each kids’ name and pray for one minute for each kid in your class this week. 
  4. Prepare a lesson plan for one lesson on one topic and, keeping in mind good/bad catechist, write one sentence that ties it to Christ. 
  5. Come up with one example from your life per lesson plan.



Never Miss an Episode!

Get show notes, exclusive bonus content, and more sent straight to your inbox.