Back to Posts
May 8, 2019

Do Aliens Exist? Fr. Spitzer and Br. Consolmogno Respond

Maggie Ciskanik

In an engaging and informative commentary concerning the History Channel’s “Ancient Aliens” documentary, Fr. Robert Spitzer addresses the question of the existence of non-intelligent life, followed by the question of extraterrestrials’ existence.

On the subject, he explains:

First, it is possible that non-intelligent alien life exists in the universe… given the fact that there are a billion trillion stars with almost as many exoplanets within the habitable zone of those stars.

This does not imply anything about God’s creation, the human soul, or God’s salvific intention. It merely shows the heights and breadth of His imagination and creative power.

Secondly, it is a completely different question as to whether there is intelligent life in the universe that corresponds to human life. If so, I would contend that such a being would have a transphysical soul—and if they have a transphysical soul, it would have to have been created by God—who is a transphysical agent.

Fr. Spitzer disputes the premises of the Ancient Aliens documentary. He insists that the “evidence” presented for alien intervention in the building of the Incan temples and the Egyptian pyramids is completely unfounded. Like Br. Guy Consolmogno, researcher and current director of the Vatican Observatory, he insists that there is no evidence of extraterrestrials in our midst.

Could you (and would you) baptize an extraterrestrial?

A few years ago I picked up a book with the amusing title “Would You Baptize an Extraterrestrial?” by Vatican Observatory scientists, Br. Guy Consolmogno and Fr. Paul Mueller, SJ. Within its pages, the authors discuss serious topics about the relationship between faith and science in humorous and lively dialogues—a kind of banter between them that manages to convey information in a memorable fashion.

Like Fr. Spitzer, both men are often asked questions. Apparently, Br. Guy has been asked many times if he would baptize an extraterrestrial, but there was one particularly memorable occasion.

Pope Benedict’s 2010 visit to Birmingham, England, coincided with a talk Br. Guy gave at the Birmingham Science Festival. He agreed to be interviewed by journalists ahead of the visit, but the only questions they asked were about conflicts between the observatory and the pope.

When Br. Guy failed to provide the hoped for answers (because the pope had only ever showed support for their work), a reporter apparently asked in frustration, “Would you baptize an extraterrestrial?” Br. Guy responded jokingly, “Only if she asked.” Hilariously, some reports the next day treated his answer as if it was the official teaching of the Church!

One of the key points these two astronomers highlight is that scientists and theologians have been writing about the possibility of alien life for several decades. However, Br. Guy makes another point emphatically: he has no evidence, nor knows anyone with evidence, that aliens exist or that there has been any kind of contact with alien intelligences. No one, he says, has artifacts from UFOs.

If it is possible aliens exist, maybe baptism would not even be necessary—if their world is unfallen, like the planets in C.S. Lewis’s Out of the Silent Planet or Perelandra. Hmm.

Where in the universe would extraterrestrials live?

Image Credit: Cameron Delafluer

In an intriguing consideration of new data about habitable planets, Magis Center Executive Director, Joe Miller, and Dr. Marisa Cristina Marsh, discussed the current number of habitable planets in our own Milky Way Galaxy. It might startle you to know that to date over 1800 exoplanets have been identified.

With 100-200 billion stars in our galaxy, there are still a lot of places to look! (Keep in mind that there are also a staggering 100-200 billion galaxies in our universe.) The question still remains: are any of these exoplanets habitable by similar life forms as those found on the earth?

Chris Graney, astronomer and regular contributor to the Vatican Observatory blog, “The Catholic Astronomer,” doubts evidence of intelligent life will be found any time soon. In a series of posts, he describes the view of the universe found in the Star Wars movies:

…the idea that the universe is full of planets like Earth that are home to lots of life and lots of intelligent life—arose following the Copernican Revolution. The Star Wars universe, which teems with all sorts of life from all sorts of more-or-less Earthlike planets, is a Plurality-of-Worlds universe.

The problem with a plurality-of-worlds view, Graney suggests, (aside from giving rise to a movie with annoying characters like Jar Jar Binks) is that the Star Wars view assumes the universe is homogeneous. Diversity and not homogeneity is what scientists actually keep finding (see Episode V for Graney’s amusing disclaimer).

Thus, the question remains, and the answer is…

So, in very Jesuitical fashion we can say:

It is possible that extraterrestrials exist, even though currently there is no evidence that they do?

Additionally, presuming they have transphysical souls in need of redemption and could understand our language and be catechized, extraterrestrials could be baptized.

If they asked.


This article was first published on the Magis Center blog. It has been republished here with permission.


You May Also Like:

A Catholic Response to the Extraterrestrial Question

The Early Church Offers Guiding Light on Epiphany

Did Jesus Predict the End and Get It Wrong?


About Maggie Ciskanik

With a bachelor of arts in philosophy, a minor in science, and a trio of graduate science classes, Ciskanik landed in a graduate nursing program. With the support of her enthusiastic husband, an interesting career unfolded while the family grew: a seven year stint mostly as a neurology nurse, fifteen years as a homeschooling mom of six, and a six year sojourn as curriculum developer and high school science teacher (which included teaching students with cognitive differences). These experiences added fuel to her lifelong interest in all things related to God’s creation and the flourishing of the human spirit—which has found a new home on the Magis Center blog.


Get your favorite Ascension content sent right to your email!

  • “It is possible that extraterrestrials exist, even though currently there is no evidence that they do?” – This is not correct. There are many evidences. If you search carefully, you will find them on the internet. I give one example of body implants extracted from humans abducted by the UFO-ET.

    The body implants, recovered from UFO-ET human abductees, have yogic powers. Such materials can grow human tissues in them; they can even get joined together automatically when broken; they are very hard to break though; diamond cutters cannot cut them. They stop functioning when taken out of the bodies of the abductees. Such implants do not cause infections in the human body, and the humans do not reject them either.

  • >

    FREE Catholic Bible Reading Plan

    This guide lists Scripture in an order that is easy to understand. Sign up for our email list to get it FREE.